The Malaysian Dilemma
" I got out on the 26th of September 2005 afternoon on bail. I was driving past the Kuala Lumpur Twin Towers on at night and I thought to myself, it does not mean anything anymore. I used to be proud to be Malaysian, the twin towers used to be a source of pride. But now, all my nationalistic pride is gone, I had just been treated like a criminal by my very own country. A country which I loved… Used to love. I used to think that this country was beautiful. But now all I see is a country so currupted [sic] and so dirty. No amount of washing will clean away this feeling. "
-- abettermalaysia
abettermalaysia, a malaysian blogger was recently arrested in a drug bust in nightclub in KL after preliminary test identifited him as a suspected drug user. ABM was put into lockup for almost 2 days and was only released when more comprehensive blood tests proved that he was drug-free . Through his blog, ABM documents his harrowing experience in lock-up and exposes the overt police corruption he and his fellow detainees saw while in custody.
beyond the alleged atrocities of the entire incident, the most telling aspect of the blog was how ABM -who claims to be very proud malaysian before the entire incident- relates his feelings in the aftermath of his arrests, and more pertinently his disillusionment at the state of corruption in the police. and judging from the comments on his blog, it is a point of view that found solidarity amongst other malaysian blogders.
i remember having a chat with a couple of my malaysian frens here in uni and all of them remarked that they had experienced demands for petty bribes at one point or another, either from the traffic police or from their driving test invigilators. they even went as far to say that it had become a 'neccessary cost' to incur just to dispense with the various inconveniences associated with not-resorting to bribing. According to Jerm n Chris, not bribing the tester is virtually means that you're doomed to failing your driving test. It's rather lamentable to know that such a vice has actually become something that is to be tolerated rather than curbed.
It is not my intention to disparage malaysia or nor to condescend the malaysian bureaucracy by comparing it to that of singapore's, for the simple reason i do not have any first hand experiences with bribery in malaysia so it would be uninformed and unfair of me to draw such a conclusion. (In fact bribery might actually be still pretty prevalent in singapore too albeit in less conspicuous form, considering how certain popular primary schools insidiously request donations to the school building fund from desperate parents who seek to enroll their kids into such primary schools.) Rather it is my belief that an exposé should deserve a wider audience and that those who are unfortunate enough to face the brunt of the scourge of such sytemic injustices shouldn never be afraid to speak out for fear of any backlash.
"I have also gotten a letter from a fellow detainee who's girlfriend was one of the 8-9 girls. She was proven innocent too, but I was denied the permission to post the letter. I will try to meet up with her and guess we'll take thing from there. From the letter, it could be seen that some of the girls were guilty and that they were jailed and that they were caught for drugs abuse before.
The letter was not written by the girl itself but by a friend of hers because she was too traumatised to write. Not many of us are as strong and as bold as some of the people that were listed on the comments of this blog. I'm not, Jack's a little stronger, and most of the rest just really want to get back to their lives and I don't blame them. Because so do I."
I did try to recommend this blog to tomorrow.sg about 3 days ago (since it has a tag on malaysia and has a fairly large malaysian readership), but it appears that the editors over at tomorrow.sg seem to have a greater penchant for more innocuous articles like knowing 'what malaysians think about shopping centres in singapore' or 'reasons why MRT rides are not boring'. Well i guess I can't fault that for that. After all, the recommendation disclaimer on tomorrow.sg did say that it seeks '...Internet content about Singapore or by Singaporeans' and being singaporeans, it would be inappropriate to post anything remotely critical about our northern brethrens ala Zoolander. Censorship is perhaps one of our defining traits as Singaporeans haha.
Sadly, abettermalaysia's blog isn't gonna be up for long. as ABM mentioned in his latest entry:
" But for reasons I do not believe many would understand, I may be shutting down this blog on Wednesday. Though I would like to see justice and to continue telling my story, my family cannot suffer because of me. I won't let that happen. "
Self-censorship motivated by the fear ofpersecution prosecution .... perhaps our malaysian brethren really aren't so different from us after all.
It should be noted that it was never the intention for abettermalaysia to demand or exact any form of retribution on the corrupted individuals. all he sought was to tell his story, and ultimately seek closure after the whole shebang.
" So I will be making a lot of noise. And hopefully the news would travel to somebody with the power to change things and justice can prevail. How many were there before me and how many will there be after me I will never know.
But a betterMalaysia begins with me. And with my friends and fellow blogger’s help, hopefully this country would just be that little bit better. Do forward this link to everybody you know, as everybody deserves to know. "
Let us give him the recognition he deserves before the demise of his blog....
-- abettermalaysia
abettermalaysia, a malaysian blogger was recently arrested in a drug bust in nightclub in KL after preliminary test identifited him as a suspected drug user. ABM was put into lockup for almost 2 days and was only released when more comprehensive blood tests proved that he was drug-free . Through his blog, ABM documents his harrowing experience in lock-up and exposes the overt police corruption he and his fellow detainees saw while in custody.
beyond the alleged atrocities of the entire incident, the most telling aspect of the blog was how ABM -who claims to be very proud malaysian before the entire incident- relates his feelings in the aftermath of his arrests, and more pertinently his disillusionment at the state of corruption in the police. and judging from the comments on his blog, it is a point of view that found solidarity amongst other malaysian blogders.
i remember having a chat with a couple of my malaysian frens here in uni and all of them remarked that they had experienced demands for petty bribes at one point or another, either from the traffic police or from their driving test invigilators. they even went as far to say that it had become a 'neccessary cost' to incur just to dispense with the various inconveniences associated with not-resorting to bribing. According to Jerm n Chris, not bribing the tester is virtually means that you're doomed to failing your driving test. It's rather lamentable to know that such a vice has actually become something that is to be tolerated rather than curbed.
It is not my intention to disparage malaysia or nor to condescend the malaysian bureaucracy by comparing it to that of singapore's, for the simple reason i do not have any first hand experiences with bribery in malaysia so it would be uninformed and unfair of me to draw such a conclusion. (In fact bribery might actually be still pretty prevalent in singapore too albeit in less conspicuous form, considering how certain popular primary schools insidiously request donations to the school building fund from desperate parents who seek to enroll their kids into such primary schools.) Rather it is my belief that an exposé should deserve a wider audience and that those who are unfortunate enough to face the brunt of the scourge of such sytemic injustices shouldn never be afraid to speak out for fear of any backlash.
"I have also gotten a letter from a fellow detainee who's girlfriend was one of the 8-9 girls. She was proven innocent too, but I was denied the permission to post the letter. I will try to meet up with her and guess we'll take thing from there. From the letter, it could be seen that some of the girls were guilty and that they were jailed and that they were caught for drugs abuse before.
The letter was not written by the girl itself but by a friend of hers because she was too traumatised to write. Not many of us are as strong and as bold as some of the people that were listed on the comments of this blog. I'm not, Jack's a little stronger, and most of the rest just really want to get back to their lives and I don't blame them. Because so do I."
I did try to recommend this blog to tomorrow.sg about 3 days ago (since it has a tag on malaysia and has a fairly large malaysian readership), but it appears that the editors over at tomorrow.sg seem to have a greater penchant for more innocuous articles like knowing 'what malaysians think about shopping centres in singapore' or 'reasons why MRT rides are not boring'. Well i guess I can't fault that for that. After all, the recommendation disclaimer on tomorrow.sg did say that it seeks '...Internet content about Singapore or by Singaporeans' and being singaporeans, it would be inappropriate to post anything remotely critical about our northern brethrens ala Zoolander. Censorship is perhaps one of our defining traits as Singaporeans haha.
Sadly, abettermalaysia's blog isn't gonna be up for long. as ABM mentioned in his latest entry:
" But for reasons I do not believe many would understand, I may be shutting down this blog on Wednesday. Though I would like to see justice and to continue telling my story, my family cannot suffer because of me. I won't let that happen. "
Self-censorship motivated by the fear of
It should be noted that it was never the intention for abettermalaysia to demand or exact any form of retribution on the corrupted individuals. all he sought was to tell his story, and ultimately seek closure after the whole shebang.
" So I will be making a lot of noise. And hopefully the news would travel to somebody with the power to change things and justice can prevail. How many were there before me and how many will there be after me I will never know.
But a better
Let us give him the recognition he deserves before the demise of his blog....
8 Comments:
Dude, read this last week. I'm not saying what the guy described could not have happened but a drug bust of 20 ppl would have rated a mention by the media, in a country that prides itself on its war against drugs.
And plus for reasons unknown to us, he's not deciding to bring this to the attention of the media or even make an official complain to his local MP, or the local Opposition representative. He may not want to sue but he can at least publicise it.
I mentioned this on Jeff Ooi's blog and that is - just because it's a blog doesn't mean it's 100% truth. If he wants to have credibility on this, he should be doing more than just blogging about it. His reasons for not doing so is just not good enough.
Fuck. And I wanted to emigrate to Malaysia..
get use to it. it's the big big world and all sort of pple are out there...
and i guess we are really very sheltered in our world here...
mooiness:yes i guess blogging about this under the shield of anoynmity certainly lends a lot less credibility for his cause. Yet at the same time, it is conceivable that he feels apprehensive about challenging the system which inherently lacks any effective form of checks and balance. I remember reading one of the comments saying how there were cases of deaths in custody such as that of a certain Francis Udayapan went largely uninvestigated. sadly, it's precisely the lack of faith in the system that detracts any efforts of rectification. it's a vicious cycle that's just gonna further embolden corruption.
of course, the large numbers of anoymous anti-UMNO spammers found on malaysian blogs probably serves to dimish abettermalaysia's credibility too.
suspiciousbastard: emigrate? considering how malaysia is gradually trying to implement a full-scale NS sorta program, do u seriously wanna risk getting enlisted into yet another 2 years of military service? LOL
spinnee: yeah i agree. in fact we are too sheltered, too intolerable of the less-than-pleasant realities beyond that of Singapore. which is probably while so many singaporean businessmen find it so difficult to do business in places like China where corruption is pretty rife.
The exact same thing happened to my friend in Singapore when he was doing NS. Drug bust at a night club, botched field test, the lab test comes back and it's OK. But it could have been worse for him because it was detention barracks instead.
Why would this make the news? This shit happens all the time without any reporting anyhow.
Sorry, the last comment should read "but it was worse for him because ...."
actually DB isn't that bad comparably i guess. my frens who went there, said the sandbag regime was the least of their concerns, the biggest problem was that of boredom. cos' they're forced to face the wall in their cell all the time.
one guy in my platoon kenna in a drug bust in Boat Quay too, and all the while he maintains that he din consume the drugs intentially cos' by some miraculous stroke, a certain 'somebody' which he claims threw the pills into their jugs of alcohol. damn far fetched lah, anyway, he went in for a year.
Post a Comment
<< Home